'Deep concerns' over UN official's trip to China's Xinjiang
China has been condemned internationally for setting up the detention complexes, which it describes as ‘education training centres’ [File: Thomas Peter/Reuters]
The United States and other western countries have objected to a visit by the United Nations counterterrorism chief to China’s remote Xinjiang region, where UN experts say about one million ethnic Uighurs and other Muslims are held in detention centres.
Vladimir Voronkov, a veteran Russian diplomat who heads the UN Office of Counter-Terrorism (UNOCT), is in China at the invitation of Beijing and is due to visit Xinjiang’s capital Urumqi, according to an email sent by his office to countries that raised concerns.
Diplomats said that along with the US several other countries, including Britain, have also complained.
US Deputy Secretary of State John Sullivan spoke with UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres on Friday “to convey deep concerns” about Voronkov’s trip because “Beijing continues to paint its repressive campaign against Uighurs and other Muslims as legitimate counterterrorism efforts when it is not”.
“The Deputy Secretary expressed that such a visit is highly inappropriate in view of the unprecedented repression campaign underway in Xinjiang against Uighurs, ethnic Kazakhs, Kyrgyz, and other Muslims,” the US State Department said in a statement.
Sullivan told Guterres that Voronkov’s trip puts the UN’s reputation and credibility at risk.
China has been condemned internationally for setting up the detention complexes, which it describes as “education training centres” helping to stamp out “extremism” and give people new skills. Western states are worried Voronkov’s visit will validate China’s justification for the centres, diplomats said.
“China will, and is, actively saying that what they’re doing in Xinjiang is good terrorism prevention,” said a UN Security Council diplomat, speaking on condition of anonymity.
“The visit by Voronkov validates their narrative that this is a counterterrorism issue, when we would see it more as a human rights issue,” said the diplomat, adding that if Voronkov did not speak out after visiting Xinjiang then “silence could be seen as implicit acceptance, at worst UN complicity”.
DepSec Sullivan spoke with @UN Secretary-General @antonioguterres to convey concerns re: Under-Secretary-General Voronkov’s planned travel to Xinjiang. The visit is egregious in view of the repression campaign in Xinjiang against Uighurs, ethnic Kazakhs, Kyrgyz and other Muslims. pic.twitter.com/lRMYbAQa7i
— Morgan Ortagus (@statedeptspox) June 15, 2019
The email from Voronkov’s office, seen by the Reuters news agency, said China planned the itinerary for Voronkov, who is the UN’s top counterterrorism official. The email said his office does “not expect any public statements” on his visit to Xinjiang.
Human Rights Watch (HRW) criticised the UN for sending a counterterrorism official instead of a human rights expert, saying it risks deflecting attention from what it called “a massive government rights violation against the Turkic Muslim population”.
Voronkov will be visiting Xinjiang before UN human rights chief Michelle Bachelet, who has repeatedly pushed China to grant the UN access to investigate reports of disappearances and arbitrary detentions, particularly of Muslims in Xinjiang.
“This mission is not connected in any manner to upcoming visits by other senior UN officials, including the High Commissioner of Human Rights. We would like to assure you that (Voronkov’s) visit is not intended to undermine or overshadow the visit of Ms Bachelet,” the email said.
Chen Xu, China’s new ambassador in Geneva, told reporters on Thursday that China had invited Bachelet to visit the camps in Xinjiang “to see for herself”.
UN spokeswoman Marta Hurtado confirmed Bachelet had met Chen and that her office is continuing to negotiate “full access” for any trip to China.
The last visit by a UN human rights chief to China was in 2005.
The email from Voronkov’s office said he had already visited Russia, Britain, the US and France which, along with China, make up the five permanent veto-wielding members of the UNSC.
HRW UN director Louis Charbonneau said that instead of sending Voronkov to Xinjiang, Guterres should “be calling for the immediate closure of ‘political education’ camps” and pushing for unfettered access for Bachelet and other rights experts.
Guterres raised the plight of Muslims in China’s Xinjiang region with the Chinese government’s top diplomat, Wang Yi, during a visit to Beijing in April.